One of the greatest temptations in the investing world is to chase the dream that penny stocks afford: the chance to truly strike it rich. In reality, most of these dreams turn into nightmares, since you often get what you paid for with low-priced names.
That said, the gold run-up has shined a spotlight on small mining stocks that have piqued the curiosity of seasoned investor Ross Healy. The chairman of Strategic Analysis Corporation is best known for his rigid focus on value stocks, which is why I was surprised to see him post a video on his YouTube channel about a gold penny stock.
But in speaking with Healy, he told me that he feels gold itself offers good value and has more room to climb. In his view, the sad state of the U.S. balance sheet will be good for gold investors, and there’s no harm in looking at some of the junior miners, so long as you realize there’s a good chance you’ll lose everything you put in. With penny stocks, he says you can “lose your shirt” as fast as you can double your money.
I spoke with him for this week’s Ticker Take about how he approaches these stocks and which ones he likes right now.
Interestingly, Healy learned about the highs and lows of penny stocks before he’d even begun his professional investing career. His first penny stock was a 12 cent name that he held for three years. It rose to 29 cents just as he was finishing his MBA, and he bought himself a Mustang. His second penny stock investment crashed, however, and burned through an inheritance he had received from his aunt.
Healy told me the lesson was to leave penny stocks to someone on the inside, or someone lucky, and he has done that ever since.
As a value investor, he follows four rules before buying a cheap stock. The balance sheet has to be strong, the price has to be below what the business is worth, and the stock has to be trending up. The fourth rule is knowing when you might sell before you even buy the stock.
When it comes to more speculative names, Healy says to be ready for changes. As an example, the YouTube video he had made was about a company called Wallbridge Mining. A few weeks later the company changed its name to Sunday Lake Gold, and his view changed with it.
During our Ticker Take discussion, Healy highlighted four speculative small caps and two bigger gold companies on his list. As always, this is not financial advice. These are Healy’s views, and small mining stocks can be highly volatile. And Healy’s message to anyone investing in small names is to keep those positions small as a portion of your portfolio.
Troilus Mining (TSX: TLG), speculative small cap
Troilus is working on a gold and copper project in Quebec. Healy is optimistic about gold and thinks small names like this could be worth a look if the price rises, though he stresses it is a speculative hunch.
Arizona Metals (TSX: AMC), speculative small cap
Arizona Metals is exploring the Kay Mine, a copper, zinc, gold and silver project in Arizona. Healy sees a “good possibility of a speculative rebound.”
Meridian Mining (TSX: MNO), speculative small cap
If gold finds a base, Healy thinks the stock could see “a nice move.”
Starcore International (TSX: SAM), speculative small cap
Starcore operates a gold mine in Mexico. Healy says juniors like this need something where “there probably is value there,” and he thinks it could do well if gold moves higher.
Alamos Gold (TSX: AGI)
Healy calls it one of the two best-run gold companies in Canada. He likes that it operates here, which he considers politically safe, and says it plans to nearly double production by 2032. He sees the stock’s recent weakness as temporary.
Agnico Eagle (TSX: AEM)
Agnico is one of the most mentioned stocks on Ticker Take since we launched. Healy likes its takeover of Kirkland Lake Gold. Agnico had the money and needed land with development potential, and Kirkland brought it. He sees it as a good long-term investment.
The Ticker Take
It says something about the gold run that a value investor like Healy is even looking at penny stocks. He is careful about it, though. The four small names are a side bet, and he says it “could be play money with a nice payoff.”
If you’d rather skip the roller coaster, Alamos and Agnico are the two he likes for the long term.
---
Jon Erlichman is a BNN Bloomberg contributor and the host of Ticker Take on YouTube.

